Skip to main content

Table 4 Cognitive performance and brain structure comparison by education level and reading activities

From: Reading activities compensate for low education-related cognitive deficits

 

Group 1

n=71

Group 2

n=223

P

Group 3

n=98

Group 4

n=67

P

Age

62.66±9.79

61.34±7.73

0.299

58.63±8.09

55.67±9.5

0.825

Gender female (n, %)

39, 54.9%

138, 61.9%

0.297

50, 51.0%

33, 49.3%

0.824

Education years

10.44±1.95

9.58±2.42

0.007

16.37±1.08

16.18±0.72

0.180

Global CDR score

0.14±0.23

0.24±0.44

0.323

0.08±0.20

0.13±0.28

0.236

MMSE

25.04±3.13

23.33±4.97

0.001

26.94±2.35

26.42±3.34

0.241

MoCA

21.26±4.05

18.9±5.37

0.001

24.9±2.82

24.22±4.52

0.280

DST total

11.59±2.27

10.45±2.53

0.001

12.82±2.26

13.21±3.19

0.387

RAVLT total learning

35.97±9.55

33.81±11.85

0.123

42.85±9.45

44.44±12.02

0.345

RAVLT long-delayed recall

6.07±3.43

6.03±3.79

0.931

8.73±3.29

8.53±3.88

0.726

ROCF copy

30.36±8.25

27.99±10.07

0.167

33.96±5.08

30.84±9.53

0.186

ROCF long-delayed recall

14.33±8.32

10.39±8.73

0.012

18.31±6.95

14.05±9.92

0.096

Stroop D time

18.19±7.84

23.31±17.69

0.001

15.91±4.35

16.75±8.88

0.419

Stroop W time

24.97±9.69

28.59±14.85

0.019

20.42±6

20.72±11.21

0.844

TMT-A time

50.89±25.93

62.56±33.49

0.003

39.39±16.34

43.62±40.19

0.419

TMT-B time

128.57±91.74

139.01±90.87

0.405

82.26±44.79

79.91±54.49

0.764

BNT

23.97±3.87

21.08±4.43

<0.001

25.77±2.81

24.96±2.45

0.057

SDMT

33.07±12.71

29.31±13.05

0.035

44.21±11.89

43.84±15.18

0.864

CDT

8.59±1.92

7.82±2.50

0.008

8.94±1.69

8.98±1.87

0.870

NPI

1.31±4.25

1.89±6.29

0.478

0.83±2.09

1.65±4.97

0.206

Brain structure

      

 Left hippocampal volume, mm2

3391.25±442.13

3372.73±419.86

0.759

3580.93±455.11

3587.09±411.2

0.93

 Left amygdala volume, mm2

1487.93±400.96

1494.7±333.99

0.889

1444.95±319.72

1443.14±289.65

0.971

 Left thalamus volume, mm2

6927.86±912.39

6868.82±894.71

0.635

6844.53±902.39

6902.71±1077.97

0.713

 Left caudate volume, mm2

3274.19±590.97

3326.22±577.32

0.518

3347.72±546.78

3204.22±589.96

0.118

 Left putamen volume, mm2

4613.36±742.16

4634.88±700.9

0.827

4647.23±600.29

4543.36±777.51

0.344

 Left pallidum volume, mm2

1958.16±291.24

1922.58±236.29

0.307

1926.63±253.55

1896.81±246.62

0.463

 Left cortex volume, mm2

215,000.93±24,471.4

216,524.19±23,482.27

0.643

212,619.25±24,800.12

213,376.89±27,526.83

0.857

 Left cerebral white matter volume, mm2

225,861.59±35,115.03

222,804.26±27,795.56

0.51

217,545.76±29,530.28

221,041.16±33,286.15

0.488

 Left mean cortical thickness, mm

2.37±0.12

2.36±0.11

0.34

2.38±0.11

2.38±0.1

0.796

 Right hippocampal volume, mm2

3533.42±467.04

3449.84±500.66

0.205

3695.9±417.79

3720.84±445.47

0.723

 Right amygdala volume, mm2

1638.97±387.11

1671.78±333.05

0.495

1646.86±334.66

1639.52±320.52

0.89

 Right thalamus volume, mm2

6739.93±910.74

6682.39±802.96

0.617

6571.9±886.17

6627.11±891.5

0.701

 Right caudate volume, mm2

3326.03±602.96

3389.53±553.2

0.418

3396.05±628.68

3257.71±572.69

0.161

 Right putamen volume, mm2

4702.98±639.94

4757.25±691.4

0.564

4723.38±655.7

4700.38±759.94

0.839

 Right pallidum volume, mm2

1939.62±285.7

1925.39±250.47

0.692

1935.71±280.49

1903.42±262.42

0.466

 Right cortex volume, mm2

214,709.43±24,120.85

216,498.29±23,889.7

0.589

211,079.33±26,149.49

213,429.13±26,517.63

0.581

 Right cerebral white matter volume, mm2

225,512.97±34,160.89

221,859.89±27,599.24

0.42

215,805.29±29,593.22

220,808.98±32,622.88

0.317

 Right mean cortical thickness, mm

2.37±0.12

2.35±0.11

0.142

2.38±0.11

2.37±0.11

0.427

 Cortex volume, mm2

429,710.36±48,310.18

433,022.48±47,001.73

0.613

423,698.58±50,582.34

426,806.01±53,831.66

0.712

Subcortex gray volume, mm2

54,504.63±6480.09

54,534.15±5891.59

0.972

54,151.2±5827.67

53,933.42±6713.47

0.828

 Total gray volume, mm2

582,730.42±62,282.68

586,201.27±58,202.35

0.672

576,181.75±62,013.7

578,021.34±65,196.6

0.858

 Cerebral white matter volume, mm2

451,374.56±69,166.21

444,664.14±55,202.29

0.463

433,351.05±58,867.31

441,850.14±65,823.54

0.396

 WM hyperintensities volume, mm2

3602.52±4963.72

3090.02±4398.62

0.416

3925.16±6044.47

2460.48±3165.75

0.048

 Brain segmentation volume, mm2

1,093,169.74±123,689.54

1,087,857.27±108,324.4

0.733

1,065,497.73±113,587.95

1,071,699.19±127,357.94

0.748

 eTIV, mm2

1,440,816.13±159,459

1,443,942.62±148,911.25

0.882

1,422,070.61±165,054.25

1,422,138.01±159,346.57

0.998

 Brain segmentation volume to eTIV, %

76.03±5.26

75.55±5.18

0.507

75.26±6.19

75.54±6.03

0.783

  1. Four groups: low education (educational years ≤12) with and without reading activities (groups 1 and 2) and high education (educational years ≥13) with and without reading activities (groups 3 and 4)
  2. Abbreviations: CDR Clinical Dementia Rating, MMSE Mini-Mental State Examination, MoCA Montreal Cognitive Assessment, DST Digit Span Test, RAVLT Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test, ROCF Rey-Osterrieth Complex Figure Test, TMT Trail Making Test, BNT Boston Naming Test, SDMT Symbol Digit Modalities Test, CDT clock drawing test, NPI Neuropsychiatry Inventory, WM white matter, eTIV estimated total intracranial volume