Fig. 4
From: Issues and recommendations for the residual approach to quantifying cognitive resilience and reserve

Associations with cognitive decline. Figures represent associations between annual slopes in memory (derived as the random slopes from a linear mixed effects model of memory regressed on time that included the whole sample) and A memory at baseline, B residuals of baseline memory regressed on hippocampal volume, and C baseline memory when hippocampal is also included as a predictor in the model. This figure illustrates that the regression coefficient (β) estimated for the memory residual in panel B (a linear regression of the form “Slopes ~ Residual”) is equivalent to the coefficient of the cognition term in a multivariable regression that includes both cognition and brain as predictors of decline (slopes ~ memory + hippocampal volume) shown in panel C. Note that panel C is a partial regression plot, in which the data points illustrate the relationship between memory slopes and cognition when covarying for brain. MEM = ADNI memory factor score